Difference between Verification and Validation
The primary difference between verification and validation is that Verification checks if the product is built right, while Validation checks if the right product is built. Apart from this, Verification is Static Testing, but Validation is Dynamic Testing.
Verification and validation are two important concepts in software testing. However, they can often be misunderstood. So, to clarify the confusion and provide a detailed explanation, we will delve into the difference between verification and validation in software testing in this article. But before we dive into that, let's take a quick look at the topics we will cover in this article.
Table of Content (TOC)
Best-suited Software Development courses for you
Learn Software Development with these high-rated online courses
- Verification and Validation Difference
- What is Verification?
- What is Validation?
- Key Differences Between Verification and Validation
Difference Between Verification and Validation
For better clarity and understanding, let's go through verification and validation differences in a tabular format.
| Aspect | Verification | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Static process of checking documents, design, code, and program to see if software is built according to requirements. | Dynamic process of testing and validating the actual product to meet the exact needs of the customer. |
| Type of Testing | Static (does not involve code execution). | Dynamic (involves code execution). |
| Methods | Reviews, walkthroughs, inspections, desk-checking. | Black Box Testing, White Box Testing, Non-functional testing. |
| Focus | Conformity to specifications. | Meeting customer requirements and expectations. |
| Bug Detection | Finds bugs early in development. | Finds bugs not caught by verification. |
| Target | Application and software architecture, specification, design, database. | Actual software product. |
| Execution Team | Quality assurance team. | Testing team with QA involvement. |
| Sequence in Development | Performed before validation. | Follows verification. |
| Nature of Checks | Checking of documents/files by humans. | Execution of program by computer. |
| Purpose | Ensures correct implementation of functions. | Ensures software is traceable to customer requirements. |
| Key Concern | Aligning with customer and business requirements at each stage. | Functioning across different conditions and environments. |
| Defect Detection Rate | Finds about 50-60% of defects. | Finds about 20-30% of defects. |
| Dependence | Based on reviewer's opinion, may vary. | Based on factual testing, often stable. |
| Emphasis | Process, standards, guidelines. | Product itself. |
| Execution Requirements | Does not require devices, platforms, browsers, OS. | Best executed using real browsers, devices, OS. |
| Question Addressed | Are we building the product right? | Are we building the right product? |
Read Later
What is Verification?
Verification in software testing is the process of evaluating software at different development stages to ensure it meets the specified requirements. This process evaluates whether the software is being built correctly according to the design documents and standards set for the project.
Verification involves a series of checks and reviews conducted throughout the software development lifecycle. It includes activities like:
- Inspecting design documents
- Performing static code analysis
- Conducting walkthroughs and reviews,
- Ensuring that the software adheres to predefined standards and guidelines, etc.
The primary goal of verification is to identify issues and discrepancies early in the development process, thus preventing significant problems in the later stages. In lay terms, the verification process answers, "Are we building the product right?"
What is Validation?
Validation in software testing is the process of evaluating the final software product to ensure it meets the intended use and fulfils the requirements of the end-users. This process focuses on verifying that the right product has been built as per the user's needs and expectations.
Validation involves a series of activities where the software is tested in real-world scenarios to confirm its functionality, performance, and suitability for the intended audience. This process includes various forms of dynamic testing, such as:
- Functional testing
- System testing
- User acceptance testing (UAT)
The primary objective of validation is to ensure that the software does what it is supposed to do and is usable in its intended environment. In lay terms, the verification process answers, "Are we building the right product?"
Key Differences Between Verification and Validation
Here are the key differences between verification and validation:
- Verification is static (no code execution), while Validation is dynamic (involves code execution).
- The verification process checks if the software meets design specifications. Meanwhile, the validation process ensures the software meets user needs and expectations.
- Verification uses reviews and inspections. On the other hand, validation involves actual testing like Black Box and White Box Testing.
- When comparing validation and verification based on the stage in development, verification occurs before validation in the development process.
- Verification focuses on design and development aspects. In contrast, validation targets the final operational software product.
- The QA team conducts verification, whereas validation is primarily carried out by the testing team with the QA team.
Conclusion
Verification focuses on ensuring that the software meets specified requirements and is built correctly according to design specifications. It answers the question, "Are we building the product right?" On the other hand, validation, seeks to determine if the software meets the needs and expectations of the end-users. It answers the question, "Are we building the right product?"
Must Read Articles:
What Does A Software Engineer Do? Roles, Responsibilities, and Skills
A Day in Life of a Software Engineer – An Interview Log
FAQs
When should I use Validate and Verify?
These are independent procedures that must be used together to ensure that a system or application meets requirements and specifications and is fit for purpose. Validation can be used as an internal process in development, scaling, or production environments. Verification, on the other hand, should be used as an external process to accept conformance from stakeholders.
UAT (User Acceptance Testing) - Validation or Validation?
UAT (User Acceptance Testing) is considered verification. Validating that a system is "fit for purpose" is the actual validation of the system or application being run by real users.
What is Verification in Software Testing?
Verification is the process of evaluating intermediate products in the software development life cycle to verify that the creation of the final product is on the right track.
What is validation?
Validation is the process of evaluating whether a product, service, or system meets the needs and expectations of the user. It ensures that the right product has been built. Validation typically involves user testing and feedback to confirm that the product fulfils its intended purpose effectively.
What is the difference between verification and validation with examples?
Verification checks if the product is built according to design specifications. Example: Checking if a button is blue as per design.
Validation ensures the product meets user needs and works in real-world scenarios. Example: Ensuring users find the button easy to use and it works as intended.
What is the primary purpose of verification?
Verification primarily aims to ensure that a product or system meets specified requirements and is built correctly. It involves checking documents, design, code, and other components to confirm that they align with the initial specifications before moving to the next development phase.
Can verification and validation co-occur?
Yes. Verification and validation can co-occur during the development process. While verification checks the correctness of the product against specifications, validation can be conducted through user testing and feedback to ensure the product meets user expectations and requirements.
What are some common methods used for verification?
Common verification methods include inspections, reviews, and static analysis. These techniques help identify defects early in the development process by evaluating documents, code, and designs against predefined criteria without executing the code.
What are the consequences of neglecting validation?
Neglecting validation can lead to significant issues, such as user dissatisfaction, increased costs for rework, and potential project failure. If a product does not meet user needs, it can result in poor adoption rates and damage the brand's reputation.
How do industry standards influence verification and validation?
Industry standards provide guidelines and best practices for conducting verification and validation. They help ensure consistency, quality, and compliance across projects, making it easier for teams to implement effective processes and achieve reliable results in product development.
Why are verification and validation necessary?
Verification and validation are crucial for ensuring product quality and reliability. They help identify defects early in the development process, reducing costs and time. These processes also enhance customer satisfaction by ensuring that the final product meets user expectations and requirements.
What are some methods of verification?
Methods of verification include inspections, reviews, and testing. Inspections involve examining the product for compliance with specifications. Reviews involve evaluating documentation and design. Testing involves executing the product to ensure it behaves as expected under various conditions.
What are some methods of validation?
Methods of validation include user acceptance testing, surveys, and field trials. User acceptance testing involves real users testing the product to confirm it meets their needs. Surveys gather user feedback, while field trials assess the product's performance in real-world conditions.
Can verification occur without validation?
Yes, verification can occur without validation. A product may be verified against specifications but may not meet user needs. However, both processes are essential for ensuring overall product quality. Relying solely on verification can lead to a technically correct product, but it is not user-friendly.
Are verification and validation applicable in all industries?
Yes, verification and validation are applicable across various industries, such as software development, manufacturing, healthcare, etc. Each industry may have specific standards and practices, but the fundamental principles of ensuring quality and meeting user needs remain consistent across all sectors.
Anshuman Singh is an accomplished content writer with over three years of experience specializing in cybersecurity, cloud computing, networking, and software testing. Known for his clear, concise, and informative wr... Read Full Bio
Top Picks & New Arrivals
