Kallakurichi Student Death Case: Advising students to study well not a crime, Madras HC
Denying the allegations, the petitioners submitted that this was a case of suicide. The girl had written a suicide note and committed suicide by jumping from the third floor of the hostel and succumbing to the injuries.
Kallakurichi Student Death Case: The Madras High Court recently granted bail to the Kallakurichi private school correspondent, his wife, the principal and two women teachers who were arrested by the police on July 17 when large-scale rioting took place on the campus pursuant to a Class XII girl’s death on July 13.
Judge peruses the post-mortem reports and says, he is convinced that it is a fit case for grant of bail The Madras High Court on Friday granted bail to the Kallakurichi private school correspondent, his wife, the principal and two women teachers who were arrested by the police on July 17 when large scale rioting took place on the campus pursuant to a Class XII girl’s death on July 13.
Justice G K Ilanthiraiyan granted the bail despite vehement objection by the State Public Prosecutor and the counsel for the victim’s parents R. Sankarasubbu. The judge pointed out that the arrests had been made only on July 17 and not July 13 despite reported recovery of a suicide note.
No evidence proving that the girl was tortured
Justice GK Ilanthiraiyan observed that there was no evidence to show that the girl had been tortured before her death. Even going by the suicide note, there was no evidence to implicate the teachers as they had merely asked the student to study well.
Teachers asking students to study a part and parcel of teaching
Regretting the recent events, the court said that teachers asking the students to study well and directing them to tell the equations was part and parcel of teaching and would not amount to abetment to suicide. Police arrested the petitioners after the parents of the deceased girl filed a complaint with the authorities suspecting the circumstances of their daughter's death. The defacto complainant, parents of the deceased, had claimed that there were injuries on the body of the girl and that this was a case of rape and murder. They alleged that the girl was raped by the sons of the correspondent and the secretary.
A clear case of suicide
Denying the allegations, the petitioners submitted that this was a case of suicide. The girl had written a suicide note and committed suicide by jumping from the third floor of the hostel and succumbing to the injuries. Even as per the suicide note, the accused teachers had merely asked her to study well. There was no evidence to show that the petitioners had instigated the girl to commit suicide.
Despite objections by the state on the ground that the suicide note attracted the offence of Section 305 IPC, the court granted bail to the accused after perusing the two postmortem reports. The Court said that as per the reports, the girl had died due to hemorrhage and shock due to multiple injuries sustained. There was no evidence to show that she had died of rape or murder. The court also perused the report produced by JIPMER confirming the findings in the postmortem report.
Thus, in view of such facts and the period of incarceration already undergone by the petitioners, the court granted them bail with conditions.