Delhi High Court Rejects Blanket Smartphone Ban in Schools, Issues Guidelines for Regulated Use

Delhi High Court Emphasizes Responsible Use Over Prohibition; CBSE, KVS to Implement Framework

The Delhi High Court has ruled that an outright ban on smartphones in schools is neither desirable nor practical, instead advocating for a structured and regulated approach to their use. Issuing a set of guidelines, the court emphasized the need for policies that balance educational benefits with the risks associated with smartphone misuse.

Justice Anup Jairam Bhambhani observed that while technology plays an integral role in education, unrestricted access to smartphones can lead to excessive screen time, cyberbullying, and distractions. The court recommended that students should not be prohibited from carrying smartphones to school but should be required to deposit them during school hours where feasible.

Key Guidelines on Smartphone Use in Schools

No Disruption in Classrooms

Smartphones must not interfere with teaching, discipline, or the overall educational atmosphere.

Use of smartphones should be prohibited in classrooms, school vehicles, and common areas.

Education on Digital Responsibility

Schools must educate students on responsible online behavior, digital manners, and ethical smartphone use.

Awareness should be created about the risks of excessive screen time, including anxiety, reduced attention span, and cyberbullying.

Limited Usage for Safety

Smartphones may be used for connectivity and safety but should not be used for entertainment or recreation.

Policy Formulation with Stakeholders

Schools should develop policies in consultation with parents, educators, and experts to ensure a balanced approach.

Policies should be flexible to accommodate different school environments.

Enforceable Consequences

Schools must establish clear disciplinary measures for rule violations.

Penalties may include temporary confiscation or restricted smartphone access for a set period.

Regular Policy Review

Given the rapid evolution of technology, smartphone usage policies must be periodically reviewed and updated.

The court’s ruling came while hearing a case involving a Kendriya Vidyalaya student penalized for smartphone misuse. Noting that past advisories by CBSE and the Delhi Directorate of Education had not yielded the desired results, the court directed that a copy of its order be sent to CBSE, the Directorate of Education, and Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan for implementation. This judgment provides a structured framework for schools to regulate smartphone use while ensuring students can access technology responsibly.

Read More

• Punjab Education Minister Objects to CBSE Board Exam Pattern, Alleges Exclusion of Punjabi; CBSE Says List ‘Tentative’
• CBSE Board Exams to be Held Twice a Year: Education Ministry Reviews Implementation Plan